A lawsuit concerning an incident in which a seal and a bankbook were stolen from a home, leading to the withdrawal of ¥8.5 million from an ordinary deposit and ¥6 million from a time deposit. The identification document used was a forged health insurance card, on which the nonexistent date “June 1, Showa 1” was recorded as the date of birth.
In its ruling, the court held that time deposits require more careful identity verification than ordinary deposits and awarded damages for the time deposit, while denying them for the ordinary deposit. This is yet another pernicious example of authentication being reduced to the combination of “possessing” a bankbook and “possessing” a seal. Ideally, the bank should bear losses from ordinary deposits above a certain deductible amount as well, and the ruling is disappointing in that it did not reach this result.
It is high time seals ceased to be recognized as a means of authentication.
Related posts

I Will Be Giving a Keynote at BTCONJP 2026: AI, “Human v.4.0,” and Identity
Business Technology Conference Japan 2026 (BTCONJP 2026) will be held on Friday, November 27, and Saturday, November 28, 2026. I’ll be giving the keynote on the…

OpenAI Launches Sign in with ChatGPT (Based on OpenID Connect)
(Work in progress; last updated 2026-10-02 12:39 JST) On September 29, at DevDay 2026, OpenAI officially announced Sign in with ChatGPT (SIWC). I would like to…

When Software Becomes Staff: Governance, Security, and Safety for Agentic AI
Below is the transcript of my keynote speech at EIC 2026 on May 19, 2026. The slides are provided as a PDF at the end of…
